If you’ve spent any time looking for Buffalo Trace bourbon lately, you know it’s not as easy to find as it used to be. Shelves that used to be well-stocked are now empty. Bottle limits have become the norm, even for longtime customers. It’s a common question at liquor stores: Why is Buffalo Trace so scarce, and is it ever coming back in full force?
What’s Causing the Buffalo Trace Shortage?
Let’s start with the basics. Whiskey isn’t like beer or vodka. You can’t just make a batch and ship it out in a week. Buffalo Trace bourbon takes years to age before it goes out to stores—sometimes 8 years, sometimes even more. That’s the heart of the issue. The bottles you see on the shelves today started maturing almost a decade ago.
The distillery takes that aging process seriously. They don’t cut corners. They use traditional methods because the flavor depends on it. Rushing bourbon is never an option for them, which makes sense if you care about taste. But it does mean that even if Buffalo Trace wanted to make more overnight, it just isn’t possible.
Booming Demand and Wild Secondary Markets
Then there’s demand. Bourbon, and especially Buffalo Trace, has caught fire in the last few years. You’ve probably seen Instagram posts, YouTube reviews, and whiskey clubs all singing its praises. What used to be a best-kept secret is now front-page news in bourbon circles and beyond.
Restaurants, collectors, and regular folks are all after those recognizable bottles. When demand explodes, but supply moves at a crawl, prices jump fast. That’s where things get a bit tricky—the so-called “secondary market” means resellers buy up bottles and flip them online for two or three times the retail price. So even if your local shop gets a shipment, there’s a good chance it goes straight to hands that resell, rather than pour.
Buffalo Trace’s Allocation System
Buffalo Trace knows their bourbon is in short supply. That’s why they’ve set up an allocation system—basically, stores and distributors get a set number of bottles, and that’s it. They decide who receives how many based on how much they’ve sold in the past or the size of the region. Some states or cities might get far less than others.
Sometimes even the distillery gift shop in Kentucky runs out early in the day, or they limit you to a single bottle. That’s not by accident, and it isn’t a marketing ploy—it’s just the only way they can spread stock as fairly as possible.
For regular shoppers, this means you might see bottles at random times, with no warning. One week there’s plenty; the next week, nothing at all.
Recent Developments: Flooding and Expansion Efforts
So, what’s happened recently? Well, earlier this year, reports of flooding in Kentucky started circulating. People were worried—were barrels ruined? Would prices go even higher? But most of Buffalo Trace’s newer warehouses, especially the big ones at Peak’s Mill, ended up safe and dry. These are metal buildings, built well above historic flood lines, with special climate controls.
That’s a relief for fans, since those warehouses store over 58,000 barrels—much of the whiskey that’s supposed to meet demand for years to come.
Buffalo Trace also hasn’t been idle. Way back in 2018, the company started pouring money—$1.2 billion, to be exact—into expanding. They began building new barrel warehouses, one every four months or so. Each warehouse can hold tens of thousands of barrels. They’ve also added fermenters in their distillery, which means more whiskey being made and aged.
The first barrels from those new warehouses are already coming of age now. For bottles that are under 9 years old, the pipeline is finally opening up. If you’re looking for Eagle Rare, Blanton’s, or even Weller, though, shortages may stick around a bit longer.
How Long Will The Shortage Last?
People want to know when things will get back to normal. The honest answer? It’s still going to take time—years, not months. That’s just how bourbon production works. Even with the new warehouses humming, Buffalo Trace has to play catch up for every year demand shot ahead of what they were making.
There’s also a bit of a plot twist: just as the company’s huge expansion started to deliver younger bourbon, the bourbon “boom” cooled off a little. Around 2023 and 2024, demand paused slightly, plus tariffs started making U.S. exports to Europe more expensive.
Those factors might make it easier to find Buffalo Trace in some places, but only by a bit. Some regions will see more bottles than before; others might still have empty shelves. The allocation system will probably stick around for the next several years.
For the long haul, that $1.2 billion investment should pay off. More whiskey is being made than ever at Buffalo Trace. But if you’re after older or special bottles, plan on hunting, making friends with your local shopkeeper—or paying extra on the secondary market.
What About Special Edition and Rare Bottles?
If you’re a collector or just like to try something new, you’ve probably noticed that high-end releases from Buffalo Trace are even harder to get than the core bourbon. An example would be Blanton’s Single Barrel or anything with the word “Antique” on the label. These bottlings take even longer to age, so the supply challenge is double. Rarity is built in from the start.
That may ease slightly as some of those new warehouse barrels mature. But old whiskey takes—well, time. No one can rush it, not even with all the building in the world. For folks who chase the rare stuff, bourbon remains closer to a hobby than a grocery run.
What’s Next for Buffalo Trace and Bourbon Fans?
Whether you’re a casual drinker or a true bourbon hunter, it looks like the shelves won’t truly refill overnight. Buffalo Trace is keeping their standards high. They’re not tempted to release whiskey early just to cash in. That matters for long-term quality, even if it’s not much comfort right now.
Industry watchers say we could see a steady flow of the regular Buffalo Trace bourbon within the next year or two, at least for the younger batches. Demand from Europe may stay flat if tariffs keep prices high, so you might start seeing more bottles on American shelves, especially in states near Kentucky.
Still, the allocation system isn’t going anywhere. That means certain local stores will remain “the lucky ones,” and some customers will keep making long drives or joining email lists, just hoping for a shot. If the secondary market calms down, prices might drop a bit, but the days of easy finds at every store seem behind us.
If you want the full backstory on how industries change when demand outpaces supply, sites like Daily Business Voice sometimes follow bourbon business updates. They break down how shortages affect both the companies behind the labels—and the people who shop for them.
The Bottom Line
Buffalo Trace’s situation is a mix of tradition, time, and timing. That whiskey in your glass took years to make, and the demand jumped faster than anyone saw coming. The distillery has poured a huge amount of money into fixing the shortage, but bourbon’s not fast food—it’s slow by nature.
You’ll see bottles appear more often as the new warehouses start to deliver, especially for whiskeys aged under a decade. The rare stuff will, for now, probably stay rare. Most bourbon drinkers are getting used to checking store shelves a little more often, keeping their expectations low, and maybe sharing a bottle with friends when they do find one.
So, if you find Buffalo Trace at retail, grab a bottle. Don’t be surprised if it takes a few more rounds of waiting before that changes. The shortage is no accident, and the solution is in motion—but it’s still a waiting game for most of us.
Also Read:
